Nestlé’s Withdrawal from Fairtrade Cocoa Purchases Highlights the Need for ‘Due Diligence’ Regulations to Address Price and Income Issues

Summary
The decision by Nestlé UK&I to abandon Fairtrade cocoa purchases and bring sustainability certification in-house, is in line with a wider corporate trend towards in-house certification in response to growing public concern over the need to promote more sustainable child labour free production practices. This can be seen as part of corporate efforts to pre-empt the introduction of potentially costly mandatory ‘due diligence’ regulations. However, moves away from guaranteed farmgate prices and cocoa farming community Premiums, which the abandonment of Fairtrade sourcing represents, demonstrates a singular lack of understanding of the underlying economic forces which drive deforestation, child labour and unsustainable farming practices. To be effective ‘due diligence’ requirements must be based on delivering a decent income to cocoa farmers and must promote thriving cocoa farming communities. To date beyond some rare corporate initiatives only Fairtrade certification has effectively addressed this issue. Without solid economic foundations, deforestation, child labour and sustainable farming practice commitments are likely to face periodic reversals whenever prices take a downturn. Read more “Nestlé’s Withdrawal from Fairtrade Cocoa Purchases Highlights the Need for ‘Due Diligence’ Regulations to Address Price and Income Issues”

What Options for Strengthened EU Regulatory Requirements Would Best Serve the Interests of African Cocoa Farmers?

 

Summary
Some form of EU regulatory initiative to promote more sustainable and child labour free cocoa production in the course of 2021 now looks inevitable. The question arises: what form should such regulatory action take, if it is to support the attainment of a decent living wage for cocoa producers? This is a critical question since poor prices and heightened poverty levels have an important bearing on the use of child labour and the pursuit of environmentally damaging cocoa farming practices.  A combination of initiatives founded on bilateral cocoa supply chain agreements between the EU and cocoa exporting countries, linked to the subsequent formulation of due diligence requirements and appropriate modifications to EU competition law, all aimed at addressing the low prices paid to farmers and ensuring net gains to the financial position of farmers as a result of the implementation of environmental and forest protection measures as well as the ending of the use of child labour, would appear to offer the greatest scope for effective action in addressing shared concerns. Read more “What Options for Strengthened EU Regulatory Requirements Would Best Serve the Interests of African Cocoa Farmers?”

Linking Bail Outs to Broader Policy Objectives

 

Summary
With both European airlines and cross channel ferry companies seeking multi-billion Euro government financed assistance programmes in the face of COVID-19 related disruptions of passenger services, the debate is underway on the need to link such public financing to wider policy objectives (e.g. GHG emission reduction targets). In this context there is also a need to link such public assistance to other broader objectives such as a restoration of freight charges for essential goods to pre-COVID-19 levels and the maintenance of freight handling capacity at pre-COVID-19 levels. This would assist in restoring existing ACP-EU supply chains for fresh fruit and vegetable imports, in the face of the severe disruptions the COVID-19 pandemic has given rise to.  This would aid economic recovery in those African and Caribbean countries whose export orientated horticultural sectors have been severely disrupted by the pandemic. It would in addition help secure fresh fruit and vegetable supplies to meet the surging consumer demand for healthy eating options in those European countries with a high import dependence for fresh fruit and vegetable supplies. Read more “Linking Bail Outs to Broader Policy Objectives”

Growing Support for Payment of the Living Income Differential in the Cocoa Sector

Summary
There is growing support for the payment of the living income differential to cocoa farmers, but with the Ghana Cocoa Board and Conseil du Café Cacao of Cote d’Ivoire insisting on the need for close monitoring of how the initiative is implemented alongside private sector sustainability schemes. The LID needs to be seen as floor price on which private sector initiatives can build to ensure cocoa farming communities not only survive but prosper. Read more “Growing Support for Payment of the Living Income Differential in the Cocoa Sector”

Evidence Suggests Extending Sugar Content Tax to Snacks Would be More Effective in Combatting Obesity

Summary
Public health concerns are leading to a gradual but sustained reduction in EU sugar sector consumption. With the EU sugar sector finding a new post-quota equilibrium this is likely to reduce market opportunities in the EU for ACP sugar exporters. This will require improved marketing of sugar in the EU and the identification and exploitation of markets beyond the EU. This will also need to include at the national level in ACP sugar exporting countries structured dialogues with the international sugar companies involved in local sugar production on a common strategy for market and revenue diversification which protects and promotes the economic well-being of local sugar farmers and sugar sector workers. Read more “Evidence Suggests Extending Sugar Content Tax to Snacks Would be More Effective in Combatting Obesity”

Pressure Mounting on Cocoa Sector Multinationals to Pay Living Wage as part of Sustainability Accreditation

Summary
The Conseil du Cafe-Cacao (CCC) in Cote d’Ivoire and COCOBOD in Ghana are proposing to withdraw support from cocoa  sustainability certification schemes unless companies commit to payment of the ‘living income differential’ designed to deliver to farmers 70% of a $2,600 a ton (Freight On Board) target price. The governments of Nigeria, Cameroon and Peru are also exploring the introduction of similar minimum prices for cocoa producers. Ethical trading companies have meanwhile endorsed the producer government’s calls for higher prices within the framework of a five principles approach to enhanced supply chain management. Read more “Pressure Mounting on Cocoa Sector Multinationals to Pay Living Wage as part of Sustainability Accreditation”

Arla Commits to Extended Dairy sector Cooperation in Nigeria

Summary
Arla has announced a new partnership for the promotion of local milk production in Nigeria as part of its Milky Way Partnership Nigeria initiative. However the focus on the development of commercially viable local milk supply chains needs to be seen against the background of the serious local constraints on the development of efficient milk-to dairy supply chains in Nigeria and the expansion and changing structure of EU milk powder exports which is delivering low priced milk powders to Nigeria for reconstitution into value added dairy products. The competitive pressure from imported milk powders is only likely to be exacerbated if a no-deal Brexit occurs which would inevitably disrupt existing EU27/UK trade in dairy products. Against this background it is highly unlikely that in the foreseeable future local Nigerian milk production will make any dent in the Nigerian dairy sector’s overwhelming dependence on imported milk powders for its dairy processing activities. Read more “Arla Commits to Extended Dairy sector Cooperation in Nigeria”

How Will ABF’s Sugar Sector Strategy Affect UK Import Demand for Sugar from Particular ACP Countries?

Summary
Under a ‘no-deal’ Brexit while concluding a ‘Continuity Agreement’ with the UK will be essential to preserving duty free-quota free access for non-least developed ACP sugar exporters, the sourcing decisions of Associated British Foods will have an important bearing on which ACP exporters will benefit from the likely increase in UK sugar prices arising from the imposition of standard MFN duties on sugar imports from EU27 countries. Competitive Southern African sugar producers closely associated with the ABF owned Illovo Group will be best placed to take advantage of UK sugar shortages and higher UK sugar prices. For Caribbean and Pacific sugar exporters the sourcing decisions of Tate & Lyle Sugars will be critical, with an important issue being the nature of the contractual arrangements to be set in place to supply sugar to the UK in the new marketing year starting 31st October 2019. Read more “How Will ABF’s Sugar Sector Strategy Affect UK Import Demand for Sugar from Particular ACP Countries?”

Minimum cocoa price initiative faces challenges

Summary
A June 2019 initiative to establish a minimum price for cocoa beans launched by the Governments of Ghana and Cote d’Ivoire faced a set-back in July when no agreement could be reached with chocolate sector representatives on how the new minimum price should be applied in practice. Cocoa farmer’s representatives have stressed the importance of ensuring any such initiative translates into higher farm gate prices for cocoa farmers. Consumer pressure on chocolate companies to fully integrate a living wage for cocoa farmers into the prices paid for cocoa beans and cocoa products is needed if the current impasse is to be overcome. Read more “Minimum cocoa price initiative faces challenges”

EU Production Growth Impacts on Both Profitability of EU Sugar Companies and ACP exports to the EU in 2018

Summary
The expansion of EU sugar production in addition to reducing the volume and value of ACP sugar exports has also undermined the profitability of EU sugar beet processing companies, with major operators such as Suedzucker looking to shut some processing plants in response to low EU sugar prices. In 2017/2018 regional EU sugar price trends in part correlated with trends in sugar production, with price falls being most dramatic in areas where the production increase was greatest. Meanwhile voluntary coupled support has held back the geographical redistribution of EU sugar production. Some ACP exporters remain dependent on the UK market while others have diversified, targeting sugar deficit regions of the EU where sugar prices have held up better. Longer term trends in EU sugar consumption do not bode well for traditional ACP sugar exporters. Brexit uncertainties will need to be taken on-board in the marketing decisions of ACP sugar exporters in the 2019/20 marketing year, with various Brexit scenarios being explored and export markets to be targeted identified accordingly. Read more “EU Production Growth Impacts on Both Profitability of EU Sugar Companies and ACP exports to the EU in 2018”