Summary
Press reports in Kenya have highlighted the continued export by EU companies of pesticide products banned for use in the EU. This gives rise to pesticide residues which lead to Kenyan products being prevented from entering the EU market. This is seen as incoherent, with calls being made for the EU to halt the production and export of pesticides which are no longer approved for use in the EU on hazardous to health ground. Currently commercial considerations play a significant role in whether re-approval is sought for specific products. Re-approvals for products which are out-of-patent are not generally sought, particularly when newer patented products are being placed on the market. Thus the absence of re-approvals does not necessarily point to a risk to human health. Clearly better dialogue processes are needed to resolve this incoherency, with, where appropriate for the protection of human health, this being extended to addressing the problems at source by banning production and export of pesticides harmful to human health. Read more “EU Needs to Tackle Toxic Pesticide Residues at Source by Banning Their Production in the EU”
Category: Topics
EU Skimmed Milk Powder Stocks Empty, But for How Long?
Summary
While EU skimmed milk powder stocks are now empty, after five years of overhanging global markets, this respite could be short lived. A no-deal Brexit could so severely disrupt trade in the dairy sector that the EC would return to skimmed milk powder (SMP) intervention buying and support for private storage of SMP. As with the measures adopted in response to the August 2014 Russian import embargo this could give rise to market consequences and trade flows which undermine efforts to promote milk-to-dairy supply chains in ACP countries, particularly in West Africa. Against this background ACP governments will need to ensure they retain the trade policy space necessary to protect local markets from disruptions where initiatives to develop and sustain local milk-to dairy supply chains are underway. Read more “EU Skimmed Milk Powder Stocks Empty, But for How Long?”
EU’s Use of Pesticide Regulations Attacked in WTO as Trade Inhibiting
Summary
The EU has been challenged in the WTO on the use of its hazard-based approach to regulating pesticides, which it is claimed can constitute a non-tariff barrier to trade. The ACP Group has endorsed the US led challenge, which includes a request for the EU to review its current approach. The EU meanwhile has asserted its unwillingness to compromise the protection of human health. However the real issue relates to the design and application of EU pesticide residue controls and other import control requirement on agricultural products. It is in regard to design and application of EU import controls where more effective dialogues are required to ensure that while protecting human health no unnecessary barriers are created. While there is general agreement on this in principle the key area of contention is how to operationalise this approach in practice. At the ACP level there would appear to be a need for: greater pan-ACP cooperation in such policy dialogues with the EU; closer coordination between producer organisation, competent authorities and diplomatic representatives in Brussels; and enhanced coordination between ACP representatives in Brussels and Geneva in international fora and bilateral discussions with the EU. Read more “EU’s Use of Pesticide Regulations Attacked in WTO as Trade Inhibiting”
Can Movement up the Cocoa Value Chain be the Key to Poverty Elimination in the Cocoa Sector?
Summary
Expanding value added cocoa processing in Ghana, alongside the promotion of cocoa farmer ownership in value added processing enterprises, offers real potential for alleviating poverty in the cocoa farming sector and supporting intergenerational renewal of the cocoa farming community. A no deal Brexit could offer substantial opportunities for expanding Ghanaian value added cocoa product exports to the UK if existing duty free-quota free access can be extended, in a context where a no-deal Brexit would see a re-imposition of standard MFN duties on imports of value added cocoa products from EU27 cocoa processing enterprises. Read more “Can Movement up the Cocoa Value Chain be the Key to Poverty Elimination in the Cocoa Sector?”
Misleading Information on Brexit and the Cocoa Sector Misses the Point on Trade Issues Faced
Summary
Misleading information posted on pro-Brexit websites on EU tariffs on African cocoa product exports is distracting attention away from real issues which need to be addressed under a no-deal Brexit scenario if the current strong trend in growth in African exports of value added cocoa products is not to be halted and ever reversed. This includes the importance of the UK government taking urgent steps to avert any disruption of commercial relations arising from the threat of a possible loss of existing duty free access for value added cocoa products to the UK market as a result of the ongoing messy Brexit process. This requires a clear UK government policy commitment to taking whatever steps necessary to ensure continued DFQF access for African value added cocoa product exports. It also requires a clear policy commitment form the UK to: maintaining in place existing MFN tariffs on imports of value added cocoa products; ensuring full pan-African cumulation under the rules of origin applied under any future UK-only trade agreements; the establishment of investment support instruments to facilitate continued movement up the cocoa value chain in Africa to serve the UK. Read more “Misleading Information on Brexit and the Cocoa Sector Misses the Point on Trade Issues Faced”
Tunisian Citrus Black Spot outbreak linked to Infected planting materials not trade in citrus fruit
Summary
Confirmation of citrus black spot infections on imports of fruit from Tunisia is being linked to the illegal importation of infected planting materials. While the outbreak suggests the infection can take root in Mediterranean production zones, it has no impact on the debate on whether trade in citrus fruit from South Africa can be a vector for disease transmission to citrus growing areas of the EU. The European Commission should continue to resist Spanish citrus producer pressure to include the Phyllosticta citricarpa infection as a ‘priority quarantine pest’, since its inclusion would carry serious trade consequences for ACP citrus exporters. Read more “Tunisian Citrus Black Spot outbreak linked to Infected planting materials not trade in citrus fruit”
The EU Mercosur Agreement Part 4 Will the Mercosur Agreement Pose a Threat to Belizean Orange Juice Exports?
Summary
Spanish citrus producers are concerned the new Mercosur trade agreement could flood the EU market with frozen orange juice concentrate. This potentially impacts on frozen orange juice exporters from Belize and South African, with this being of particular concern to Belize where these exports constituted 1.3% of total exports to the EU in 2018. The conclusion of the Mercosur agreement could give added importance to exploiting the ‘rolled-over’ CARIFORUM-UK ‘Continuity Agreement’, given the potential trade disruptions which could arise from a ‘no-deal’ Brexit for the export of reconstituted orange juice and domestic EU27 orange juice to the UK. Read more “The EU Mercosur Agreement Part 4 Will the Mercosur Agreement Pose a Threat to Belizean Orange Juice Exports?”
The EU-Mercosur Agreement Part 3: Will the Mercosur Agreement Pose a Threat to the Stability of EU27 Banana Markets
Summary
EU banana producers have expressed fears over the impact any EU-Mercosur banana tariff concessions could have on the level of banana imports from Brazil. Based on recent trends in EU banana imports in response to tariff reductions these fears have solid foundations. However from an ACP perspective such fears should not be overstated with the likely market effects of increased Brazilian banana exports to the EU needing to be seen in the context of all the wider sources of pressure on the EU market position of ACP banana exporters. Individual ACP banana exporters will need to evaluate the specific implications of any new Mercosur agreement tariff concessions for the particular EU banana market components they serve. Where necessary enhanced marketing and product differentiation strategies will need to be set in place in order to maintain their current export trade to the EU. However, it needs to be recognized this will not be possible for all existing ACP banana exporters. Read more “The EU-Mercosur Agreement Part 3: Will the Mercosur Agreement Pose a Threat to the Stability of EU27 Banana Markets”
The EU-Mercosur Agreement Part 2: EU Sectoral Impacts and Implications for the ACP
Summary
The main products of concern to ACP countries where quota restricted duty free access is to be phased in for Mercosur exporters are sugar; ethanol; beef; poultry meat; and rice. The TRQ granted for sugar will reduce the margins of tariff preference enjoyed by ACP sugar exporters on EU27 markets and intensify price pressure on ACP sugar suppliers. It will make supplying the EU27 market increasingly difficulty for all but the most competitive ACP sugar exporters, unless some form of quality differentiated offering is on sale. In contrast the TRQ for ethanol is likely to have little impact on current ACP exports which are marginal. The TRQ for beef could generate increased competition on beef market components which Namibian exporters are increasingly targeting, although further investment in quality based product differentiation could serve to insulate Namibian exporters from any adverse price effects. In the poultry meat sector the new TRQ could serve to further fuel the growth in EU exports of frozen poultry parts to African market. In the rice sector given the relatively small size of the TRQ granted to Mercosur exporters it is unclear to what extent this poses a threat to ACP rice exporters in Guyana and Suriname. Read more “The EU-Mercosur Agreement Part 2: EU Sectoral Impacts and Implications for the ACP”
Ghanaian Banana Exporters Spell Out Implications of Loss of DFQF Access to UK Market
Summary
Failure to ensure a basis for continued DFQF access for Ghanaian banana exports to the UK market could result in the loss of supply agreements as a result of the inclusion of ‘delivered duty paid’ requirements in current UK super market tendering arrangements. The UK government urgently needs to decide upon the basis for providing continued DFQF for Ghanaian exports on an interim basis, while the regional complications around concluding regional West African reciprocal trade agreements, arising from the Nigerian governments reluctance to sign on to such agreement, are resolved. Speedily setting in place the regulatory measures required to ensure continued DFQF access for Ghanaian banana exports can be seen as vital to ensuring successful tenders are made for the current banana supply contracts being placed by UK supermarkets. Read more “Ghanaian Banana Exporters Spell Out Implications of Loss of DFQF Access to UK Market”