Summary
The UK government is urging businesses to use the services of freight forwarders and other customs intermediaries, to facilitate the smooth functioning of post Brexit UK/EU border clearance operations. However, the NAO reports the necessary expansion of the customs intermediate sector has simply not occurred and is unlikely to take place until the second half of 2021 at the earliest. This will see both rising costs and shortages of customs intermediaries, which could slow down border clearance operations. The resulting delivery delays could strip value out of ACP short shelf life product triangular supply chains. Urgent action is needed to secure the services of customs intermediaries for ACP trading operation along triangular supply chains in 2021. Unfortunately, given the surging demand for the services of customs intermediaries such actions may already be too late. Read more “Effective Engagement with Expanded Freight Forwarding Sector Seen as Critical to Future UK/EU Border Clearance Operations”
Category: Regions
EU27 Poultry Sector Surprisingly Resilient in Face of Covid-19 Challenges, But Brexit Challenges Could See Expanded Export Drive to ACP Markets
Summary
The EU poultry meat sector has proved surprisingly resilient to Covid-19 trade and market disruptions. While both EU imports and exports have fallen, exports of poultry meat to the main sub-Saharan African markets have risen dramatically. This role of sub-Saharan African markets as “markets of last resort” raises concerns about the impact of a ‘no-deal’ or ‘Thin FTA’ outcome to the Brexit process on international trade in poultry meat given the scale of current mutual EU/UK trade (1.2 million tonnes per annum). There are fears ACP markets could be targeted should this EU/UK trade be disrupted. This could then disrupt established or emerging African poultry sectors. ACP governments will need to prepare for these likely export surges, in a context where the EU’s new Chief Trade Enforcement Officer will be increasingly seeking to remove current trade restrictions on EU poultry meat exports, where these violate trade agreement commitments. Greater transparency in trade statistics on EU poultry exports to developing country markets could facilitate operationalising EU policy coherence for development commitments, particularly if a ‘window’ were opened through which the concerns of local ACP poultry producers could be made known. Read more “EU27 Poultry Sector Surprisingly Resilient in Face of Covid-19 Challenges, But Brexit Challenges Could See Expanded Export Drive to ACP Markets”
Uncertainties Arising from Unresolved Future EU/UK Trade Issues Generate Contract Negotiation Challenges for ACP Exporters
Summary
There area host of Brexit related uncertainties overhanging the negotiation of ACP-UK supply contracts for 2021, which threaten to increase costs to such an extent as to erode the profitability of a range of ACP exports to the UK market. ACP short shelf life product exports along triangular supply chains are likely to be most severely affected. The currency issue will also affect direct ACP exports. How these short-term issues are dealt with, could carry long term implications, especially for small scale ACP exporters. Public policy interventions to support Codes of Conduct for dealing with the distribution of additional costs, based on the principles enshrined in the EU UTP directive, could usefully be launched. In the EU, traders in short shelf life products would appear to have a long term vested interest in short term burden sharing initiatives; otherwise ACP exporters will be compelled to seek out new direct routes in serving UK markets. Read more “Uncertainties Arising from Unresolved Future EU/UK Trade Issues Generate Contract Negotiation Challenges for ACP Exporters”
Growing Importance of Raising the Farm Gate Price of Cocoa to the Elimination of Child Labour in Cocoa Supply Chains Recognised, but Strong Headwinds Faced
Summary
While proportionally the use of child labour has not increased in line with the expansion of cocoa production, data suggests some 1.56 million children continue to be employed in the Ghanaian and Ivorian cocoa sectors. NGOs campaigning on child labour issues have condemned 20 years of failure and criticised the focus on public relations rather than substantive solutions. The persistent nature of the challenge faced has been recognised, as has the central issue of net farm gate prices. While the LID payment initiative has been welcomed, a major four-fold increase in farm gate prices is held to be necessary to ‘move the dial’ on the use of child labour in cocoa farming in West Africa. Currently the benefits of the LID payment are dwarfed by losses arising from cocoa market price volatility. Getting to grips with the net farm gate price issues, in ways which ‘move the dial’ on the use of child labour, can be seen as the critical issue to be addressed in the coming months in drawing up EU ‘due diligence’ regulations related to the cocoa sector. Read more “Growing Importance of Raising the Farm Gate Price of Cocoa to the Elimination of Child Labour in Cocoa Supply Chains Recognised, but Strong Headwinds Faced”
The Prospect of UK Port Chaos Could Open Up Opportunities for the UK Government to Fulfil Its Policy Commitment to Ensuring Continuity in Trade With Developing Country Partners Within the Brexit process
Summary
With some UK ports already facing unacceptable delays in unloading ships and with the BPA warning of the ‘impossible’ demands for the implementation of new import controls in 2021, setting in place border clearance systems to facilitate the continued smooth flow of ACP fresh food and plant products to the UK via ports of landing in the EU would appear a ‘no brainer’. The establishment of a “Green Corridor” system for the border clearance of products where necessary phytosanitary and safety controls have been caried out upon entry to the EU, and duty-free/quota -free access is enjoyed to both the EU and UK market, would appear a simple means of easing pressure on UK ports. What is more, it would simultaneously fulfil the Uk governments policy commitments to ensuring ‘continuity’ in trade with developing country partners within the Brexit process. Read more “The Prospect of UK Port Chaos Could Open Up Opportunities for the UK Government to Fulfil Its Policy Commitment to Ensuring Continuity in Trade With Developing Country Partners Within the Brexit process”
Signed Cote d’Ivoire-UK EPA Leaves Major Triangular Supply Chain Issues Unaddressed
Summary
The UK-Cote d’Ivoire EPA includes commitments which are ambiguously formulated, and which fail to clearly accommodate changes since the initial drafting of the EU EPA text in 2007 as well as evolving intra-regional trade arrangements in West Africa. Particular concerns arise over the apparent retro-active nature of the bulk of Ivorian tariff phase down commitments,, which would result in the elimination of tariffs on the bulk of its imports from the UK from the date of entry into force of the UK-Cote d’Ivoire EPA (or even from the date of its provisional application). This would be both extremely unusual and unreasonable and needs to be clarified in light of the provisions of Article 13(a) and wider intentions of the agreement to replicate the situation at the date of lapsing of the applicability of the EU agreement to the territory of the UK, prior to the entry into force of the agreement. There are also major shortcomings in how the agreement deals with the future functioning of Ivorian triangular supply chains, which in some sectors account for the bulk of Ivorian sales on the UK market. The most serious issues are faced in cocoa product and preserved tuna supply chains, but with phytosanitary import control and broader border clearance and logistical issues also being faced in the tropical fruit sector. The agreement also lacks forward looking provisions on rules of origin, which in light of the continued right of UK producers to use EU inputs as if they originate in the UK, should allow the automatic use of any African input in goods produced in Cote d’Ivoire, without any loss of originating status and preferential access. Such forward looking rules of origin would encourage greater value-added processing in Cote d’Ivoire and support and promote the development of intra-African supply chains. The only means by which such an agreement can be considered minimally adequate is if it allows continued duty-free access to the UK market, but defers implementation of reciprocal commitments, until all outstanding issues of concern have been addressed.
Read more “Signed Cote d’Ivoire-UK EPA Leaves Major Triangular Supply Chain Issues Unaddressed”
If Negotiations Fail No Deal Trade Effects Likely to be Felt in Final Weeks of 2020
Summary
With UK and EU exporters of short shelf life products fearing severe trade disruptions in the first weeks of 2021, the question arises: what strategies should ACP exporters serving the UK market via the EU seek to set in place? This will require careful planning. Possible options include moving over to direct exports to the UK, shifting to onward shipping via UK east coast or inland ports to side-step Kent traffic congestion, or diversifying markets away from the UK. If routes to markets cannot be adjusted a critical issue will be the distribution of the additional costs within the supply chain (of which currency depreciation is one dimension). This will also require careful attention, particularly in regard to contractual arrangements for the delivery of goods to the UK at the beginning of 2021. If ACP exporters exclusively bear the additional logistical costs and losses arising from delays, this could undermine the commercial viability of such exports. A no-deal UK departure could also lead to both EU and UK export surges of certain agri-food products to 3rd country markets. This is particularly the case not only for poultry meat and long-life dairy products, but also products like onions, where alongside West African markets the UK market is a major market for Dutch traders. Were such export surges to threaten local producers, ACP governments would need to look at adopting remedial trade policy measures. Where no local ACP production is affected, ACP importers could capitalise on low priced ‘surpluses’ arising as a result of EU/UK trade disruptions. Read more “If Negotiations Fail No Deal Trade Effects Likely to be Felt in Final Weeks of 2020”
UK Decision to Roll-Over Recognition of EU Issued Organic Certification for Whole of 2021 Welcome News for ACP Organic Exporters, But IT Constraints Will Be Faced
Summary
The UK will continue to recognise EU issued organic certification until the end of 2021. This will avoid any loss of commercial value on ACP exports to the UK market arising from the lapsing of the validity of organic certification issued by EU27 based agencies. The issue of the lapsing of EU recognition of UK issued organic certification from 1st January 2021 however remains unresolved, with an ACP coordinated political initiative in this regard now urgently needed. The UK will however, need to move over to a system of manual organic import controls, given the lapsing of UK access to the EU TRACES system from 1st January 2021, with this potentially causing delays and increasing the administrative cost of clearing organic products through UK border controls. Read more “UK Decision to Roll-Over Recognition of EU Issued Organic Certification for Whole of 2021 Welcome News for ACP Organic Exporters, But IT Constraints Will Be Faced”
Strict Management of Sugar ATQ Necessary on Public Health Grounds Given Failure of Voluntary Measures to Reduce UK Consumption of Hidden Sugars
Summary
Voluntary sugar reduction efforts have proved largely ineffective in reducing the use of sugar in food and drink products in the UK, with the DISL in contrast demonstrating how the ‘price’ of sugar can influence the product re-formulation efforts of companies. This suggests the UK’s future sugar trade policy should be managed in a way which carefully balances the supply and demand situation on the UK sugar market, so as to maintain sugar prices and prevent surplus supplies depressing sugar prices. Otherwise, the UK’s sugar trade policy could unnecessarily depress UK sugar prices, to the detriment of wider public health policy objectives. Read more “Strict Management of Sugar ATQ Necessary on Public Health Grounds Given Failure of Voluntary Measures to Reduce UK Consumption of Hidden Sugars”
With No Deal Brexit Preparation Underway in UK and Serious Challenges Faced ACP Exporters Will Need to Look to “Brexit Proofing” Their Supply Chains
Summary
The announcement by the UK government of new inland Border Control Posts is seen as ‘extremely last minute’, with serious road freight disruptions along the main EU/UK Ro-Ro routes through Kent now seen as almost inevitable. The UK is seen as ‘dangerously ill-prepared’ for leaving the EU customs union and single market on 1st January 2020. As a consequence, significantly large increases in costs of moving goods through EU/UK border controls are likely. However, there are expanding freight options for delivery to UK East Coast and ‘inland’ ports which will side-step traffic congestion in Kent. ACP exporters using triangular supply chains need to adequately prepare for these changes and actively seek to “Brexit-Proof” their supply chains. ACP exporters directly serving the UK market will also need to take similar “Brexit-Proofing” initiatives, with successful companies potentially being able to capitalise on the rising food prices projected for the UK market in 2021. Read more “With No Deal Brexit Preparation Underway in UK and Serious Challenges Faced ACP Exporters Will Need to Look to “Brexit Proofing” Their Supply Chains”