Summary
While even under an EU/UK FTA mutual trade in agri-food products will be adversely affected, under a no-deal outcome these effects would be far more severe. Thus, under an FTA it is estimated UK food exports to the EU would fall 22.5%, while under a no-deal outcome the decline would be 63.2%. The corresponding figures for EU food exports to the UK are 22.6% and 61.7% respectively under an FTA or no-deal scenario. This would have substantial market and wider trade consequences. The knock on effects of the outcome of the EU/UK negotiations will be felt in 5 main areas:
o The effects on ACP triangular supply chains serving the UK via the EU.
o The effects on ACP triangular supply chains serving the EU via the UK.
o A possible further revision of the UK’s MFN tariff schedule under a no-deal outcome.
o New opportunities for increased direct exports to the UK market.
o The diversion of displaced EU/UK exports to targeted ACP market.
ACP agri-food sector enterprises and governments will need to make preparations for dealing with the trade and market consequences which will arise under both an EU/UK FTA and more seriously, the growing prospect of anon-deal outcome to the ongoing negotiations. Read more “Report Spells Out Impact of Brexit Scenarios for Food and Beverage Supply Chains”
Category: Caribbean
Implementation of New EC Organic Products Regulation Postponed but Unresolved Brexit Issue Threatens Commercial Gains of ACP Organic Production
Summary
The deferment of the implementation of EU’s new organic regulation offers a precedent for addressing the commercial losses ACP organic exporters face if there is no EU/UK organic equivalence agreement in place by 1st January 2021. The lapsing of EU/UK mutual recognition of organic certification on 3rd country products should be deferred until the end of the Covid-19 pandemic plus 9 months, given the travel restrictions and social distancing requirements which complicate the securing of UK or EU27 specific organic certification at the present time. This would avert needless commercial losses for ACP organic exporters and encourage the continued growth in ACP organic exports, which are wholly consistent with both EU and UK sustainability objectives. Read more “Implementation of New EC Organic Products Regulation Postponed but Unresolved Brexit Issue Threatens Commercial Gains of ACP Organic Production”
Greenpeace Highlights Trade Policy Payback for Tate & Lyle Sugar for Brexit Support
Summary
Greenpeace has drawn a link between Tate & Lyle Sugars support for Brexit an the 260,000 duty free autonomous quota for sugar established by the UK government, suggesting this trade measure, which will solely benefit Tate & Lyle Sugars, is a reward for earlies political support. Greenpeace believes it will encourage imports of environmentally damaging sugar, mainly from Brazil and harm existing ACP/LDC sugar exporters, while NFU and British Sugar believes it will harm domestic UK sugar beet producers. The effects of the ATQ however will be determined by choices made by the UK government, namely whether it conclude an FTA with the EU and whether the ATQ is used solely as a market stabilisation mechanism or becomes an integral part of the supply equation. These two choices will determine whether less efficient ACP sugar exporters are driven out-off the UK market and the income gained by the remaining ACP suppliers. Read more “Greenpeace Highlights Trade Policy Payback for Tate & Lyle Sugar for Brexit Support”
Road Haulage Issues Likely to be Critical Bottleneck Along ACP Triangular Supply Chains from 1st January 2021
Summary
The scale of the road transportation disruptions along EU/UK supply routes as a result of the UK’s departure from the EU customs union and single market and the consequent creation of border controls are increasingly becoming apparent. The main impact will be unaffected by the outcome of the ongoing EU/UK negotiations. Against this background ACP exporters currently using triangular supply chains may have little choice but to move over to direct exports to final destination markets or the abandonment of markets in the UK, mainland EU or the Republic of Ireland currently served along triangular supply chains. Read more “Road Haulage Issues Likely to be Critical Bottleneck Along ACP Triangular Supply Chains from 1st January 2021”
UK Abrogation of Withdrawal Agreement Commitments Heightens Danger of a No Deal UK Departure from the EU Customs Union and Single Market
Summary
The UK governments’ decision to breach substantive provisions of the Northern Ireland Protocol to the jointly agreed Withdrawal Agreement threatens to make ratification of any EU/UK agreement which may still be concluded extremely difficult. It increases the prospect of an acrimonious no-deal UK departure from the EU customs union and single market at the end of 2020. While the scope exists for policy measures to minimise the negative impact of a no deal UK departure on ACP exports, the window of opportunity for taking these necessary measures is rapidly closing. The absence of appropriate policy intervention will leave ACP exporters alone in facing the cost increasing challenges of a no-deal UK departure will generate. Not all current ACP exporters will be able to adjust to these new commercial realities, with all but the largest and best prepared ACP exporters being squeezed out of UK and some EU27 markets. Read more “UK Abrogation of Withdrawal Agreement Commitments Heightens Danger of a No Deal UK Departure from the EU Customs Union and Single Market”
UK Launches Consultation on its 260,000 Tonne Autonomous Tariff Quota for Raw Cane Sugar Imports
Summary
The UK government has launched a public consultation on its new 260,000 tonnes duty free sugar ATQ. A critical issue will be how the UK manages the ATQ. Given the profound uncertainties around the future supply situation on the UK sugar market arising from the unresolved EU/UK trade negotiations a strong case exists for the adoption of a carefully managed application of the sugar ATQ, with its deployment being regulated to prevent both the emergence of supply surpluses or supply deficits on the UK market in the course of 2021. Such an approach would be beneficial to both ACP/LDC sugar exporters and domestic UK sugar beet producers and processors and could also support the attainment of public health policy objectives, if it was used to foster a gradual increase in UK sugar prices. Two complicating factors however exist, namely: the depth of the impending Covid-19 recession in the UK and the serious commercial challenges facing Tate & Lyles Sugar, which desperately needs to expand the capacity utilisation of its Thames refinery in the context of more remunerative market prices for sugar. The question arises as to whether the experience and capacity exists in the hard pressed UK government administration for the nuanced and sophisticated management of the new sugar ATQ. Read more “UK Launches Consultation on its 260,000 Tonne Autonomous Tariff Quota for Raw Cane Sugar Imports”
Structural Price Pressures on UK Banana Market See Winfresh-UK Placed into Administration
Summary
It is unclear what the implications will be for St Lucian banana exports of Winfresh-UK being placed in administration. While efforts are underway to draw Fyffes into a greater role in the marketing of St. Lucian bananas in the UK, it is unclear whether the inclusion of St. Lucian bananas would add value to Fyffes product portfolio, given the uncertainties surrounding the future of the UK banana market. While in May 2020 the UK proposed to retain in place existing MFN tariffs on banana imports beyond 1st January 2021, the UK food price inflation effects of a no-deal UK departure from the EU customs union could see a further revision of the UK MFN tariff schedule, with a move over to the ‘zero production- zero MFN tariff’ approach long advocated by the global trade liberalisation wing of the Conservative Party. St. Lucian and other ACP Bananas exporters would be highly vulnerable to such a policy shift, with this uncertainty making it extremely difficult to plot a way forward for St. Lucian banana exports as supply contract negotiations for 2021 get underway. Read more “Structural Price Pressures on UK Banana Market See Winfresh-UK Placed into Administration”
How Helpful is the ECs Orientation in EU Trade Policy Review Consultation in addressing Post Covid-19 Recovery Challenge in ACP Countries?
Summary
The EU consultation note on the revision of its trade policy in light of recent developments, has introduced the concept of ‘Open Strategic Autonomy’ as a model for the design and future implementation of EU trade policy. This concept is designed to allow the EU greater policy space in defending EU economic and trade interests, while allowing the EU to more forcefully pursue its long standing policy of preferentially opening up 3rd country markets to EU exports. This is to be realised through the activities of the newly established EU Chief Trade Enforcement Officer. This approach could carry serious implications for the implementation of the ACP EPAs, agreed with the EU as long ago as 2007. It could limit the active use of established trade policy measures in support of post Covid-19 recovery. This despite the relevance of the initial Strategic Autonomy concept to the post Covic-19 socio-economic recovery needs of ACP counties. Current realities in ACP countries require the maintenance and expansion of policy space for measures to reduce the economic vulnerability and enhance the economic resilience of ACP countries. This suggest a need to subordinate the definition and enforcement of EPA commitments to the strategic autonomy needs of ACP countries, defined in light of their specific Covid-19 revealed vulnerabilities. Read more “How Helpful is the ECs Orientation in EU Trade Policy Review Consultation in addressing Post Covid-19 Recovery Challenge in ACP Countries?”
Implications for ACP Exporters of Further Reductions of Import Tariffs on Ecuadorian Bananas
Summary
At the beginning of 2020 Ecuador secured the benefits of the tariff reductions included in the EU-Andean Pact FTA. Ecuadorian exporters believe this will further stimulate banana exports to the EU, in a context where Ecuador already accounts for 1 in 4 bananas imported to the EU. It is unclear what the impact of the Covid-19 pandemic will be on Ecuador’s banana export trade to the EU. The Ecuadorian experience highlights the importance of the tariffs applied to banana imports on trade flows. In this context two issues arise for African banana exporters, namely: the future MFN tariffs the UK plans to apply to banana imports after it has left the EU customs union and whether the UK will unilaterally roll over existing duty free access for Ghanaian, Cameroonian and Ivorian banana exports, given the Covid-19 interruptions of ongoing negotiations on ‘UK-only’ Continuity Agreements which were intended to replace the EU trade agreement which will lapse once the UK leaves the EU customs union. African banana exporters have actively made their economic development concerns known to the UK government. It remains to be seen just how the UK government will respond to these concerns. Read more “Implications for ACP Exporters of Further Reductions of Import Tariffs on Ecuadorian Bananas”
Criticisms of New Rainforest Alliance Banana Certification Standards Highlights Centrality of Price Issues to Sustainability Efforts
Summary
The new Rainforest Alliance certification standard has been criticised by Latin American banana producers for failing to get to grips with the structural problems of cost and revenue distribution along the supply chain. While Rainforest Alliance is keenly aware of the problem, it holds certification alone cannot solve this structural imbalance. Rainforest Alliance is therefore looking to use other tools to leverage changes in cost and revenue distribution along banana supply chains. This could usefully focus on ensuring the inclusion of provisions on cost and revenue distribution in any EU ‘Green Deal’ regulatory initiatives aimed at promoting compliance with environmental and climate change concerns, and their coordinated implementation alongside the EU’s Unfair Trading Practices regulation. This could provide a means of getting to grips the long-term structural concerns of banana producers. Read more “Criticisms of New Rainforest Alliance Banana Certification Standards Highlights Centrality of Price Issues to Sustainability Efforts”